Household Debt Shrank Last Quarter. Cards and Car Loans Went the Other Way.

Total US household debt fell to $18.8 trillion in the second quarter, down about $13 billion from the prior quarter, according to the New York Fed's latest credit report. A decline in aggregate household borrowing is rare enough to be worth a second look, and the second look is where it gets interesting.

The drop came almost entirely from mortgages, where balances fell roughly $74 billion as high rates kept people in place and paydowns outran new originations. Credit card balances rose about $21 billion over the same three months and auto loans rose about $28 billion. The headline went one way because the largest category did; the categories that track month-to-month household strain went the other.

Sponsored by Brownstone Research

Where to invest $2 to play the $2.6 quadrillion tech beloved by billionaires

Editor’s Note: What if you could claim a stake in a technology set to become 100X bigger than Bitcoin… starting with just $2? Click here to see the details from investing legend and Washington D.C. insider Jeff Brown — the man who picked Bitcoin, Tesla, and Nvidia before they exploded higher. Or read more below.

Dear Reader, 

The world’s richest man, Elon Musk, is quietly investing in this technology…

(But it’s not AI, robotics, crypto, or rocket ships…)

The CEO of BlackRock Larry Fink believes it will be 100 times bigger than Bitcoin…

Yet is still like where the internet was in 1996.

The billionaire CEO of Coinbase Brian Armstrong is investing heavily.  

He believes this tech is “opening up a golden age for freedom” in America. 

And the founder of Robinhood — Vlad Tenev — calls this tech a “freight train” that will “eat” the entire financial system.

So why are ALL these billionaires circling this odd new technology like frenzied sharks? 

According to my 6-year analysis…

It’s because this technology will have an impact 90 times bigger than AI and 1,900 times bigger than Bitcoin.

Yahoo Finance says this tech “May Unlock $400 Trillion. 

Click here to get the details behind this technology, and how just $2 is all you need to claim a stake in the biggest financial event since 1973.  

Regards,

Jeff Brown
Founder & CEO, Brownstone Research

Two different things are being measured

Mortgage debt is a stock built over decades and it moves with housing activity, not with whether a household had a hard August. When mortgage rates sit near multi-decade highs, transactions slow, fewer new mortgages are written, and existing borrowers amortize. The balance falls for reasons that have nothing to do with financial comfort.

Revolving credit is the opposite. A card balance rises when spending outruns income in a given month, which is why it is the more sensitive read on the household budget. Auto loans sit in between, driven by vehicle prices and financing terms as much as by need, and both vehicle prices and loan sizes have stayed high.

So the composition matters more than the total. An economy where mortgage debt shrinks while card and auto balances grow is one where the long-term borrowing channel is frozen and the short-term one is doing more work.

Delinquency data that points in two directions at once

Whitmore's Watchlist:
COF (Capital One Financial Corporation): A card-heavy lender whose provisioning responds directly to revolving credit performance.
ALLY (Ally Financial Inc.): Concentrated in auto lending, the category where new delinquencies have been most stubborn.
XLY (Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR Fund): Broad exposure to the spending that credit growth is currently financing.

The aggregate numbers look reassuring. The flow into serious delinquency, meaning 90 days or more past due, fell to 2.57% in the second quarter from 2.91% a year earlier. Delinquency rates across most products have held roughly steady for two years.

Underneath that, new delinquencies on credit cards and auto loans remain at elevated levels and ticked modestly higher. The New York Fed thought the divergence between different card delinquency measures was interesting enough to publish a separate analysis explaining why data sources disagree. When the people who own the data feel the need to reconcile it publicly, the honest reading is that the consumer picture is genuinely mixed rather than clearly deteriorating or clearly healing.

That fits the rest of the macro data. The unemployment rate has held near 4%, payrolls have stopped growing, and inflation has stayed above 4% on the Fed's preferred measure. Households are employed and paying their bills, and they are financing more of ordinary life on revolving credit while doing it.

What it means for positioning

Consumer lenders are the most direct exposure, and their earnings turn on the gap between what they charge and what they lose. Credit costs are still normal by historical standards, so the risk is not an imminent credit event. It is that provisions grind higher for several quarters while funding costs stay elevated because the Fed is not cutting.

Home equity lines are worth watching alongside them. HELOC balances rose again in the quarter and now stand around $459 billion, having grown steadily for several years. Households sitting on low fixed-rate mortgages will not refinance into current rates to access equity, so they borrow against it instead. That is a rational response to the rate environment, and it also means more household borrowing is now floating-rate, which ties monthly payments directly to whatever the Fed does next.

The read-through for consumer-facing companies is subtler. Spending financed by rising balances is real spending, and it supports revenue right up until it does not. That makes the trajectory of card balances a more useful leading indicator for discretionary retail than the monthly spending headline itself.

Whitmore's Take: A falling debt total driven by frozen mortgage activity is not the same as households deleveraging. Watching the card and auto lines separately gives a clearer picture of the consumer than the aggregate ever will.

Written by Daniel Whitmore
Millionaire Insiders